observation

Who Stands Next to Whom: Reading a Herd Through Proximity Patterns

Nobuyuki Nonaka

22 Dec 2025 — 2 min read

Hook

If you want to understand what’s really holding a herd together, don’t start by looking for the biggest horse “in charge.” Start by noticing something quieter: who keeps choosing to be near whom.

Basic concept

A stable herd isn’t mainly held together by constant fighting. Much of the visible “order” comes from relationships that reduce friction—horses arranging themselves through distance, timing, and tolerance.

Proximity patterns are one of the easiest field-friendly ways to see those relationships. The key is repeatability: a single moment of standing near each other can be coincidence, but the same pair repeatedly choosing to stand or rest close suggests a meaningful bond or a reliably low-tension relationship.

This matters because “dominance” isn’t a permanent personality label, and “leadership” isn’t one fixed boss. Who yields to whom—and who moves first—can shift with the situation and the resource. Proximity gives you a steadier lens: it highlights who is comfortable together before any resource pressure shows up.

What to look for (simple and specific)

Repeated pairing: Do the same two horses consistently end up shoulder-to-shoulder when things are calm?
Resting choices: When the herd settles, who lies down or stands relaxed near whom?
Calm following without pressure: Who drifts after whom at an easy pace, without pinned ears or rushing?

Simple examples

Example 1: The “always nearby” pair
Two horses repeatedly stand within a few steps of each other across the day. You don’t see dramatic gestures—just calm closeness. This often points to a relationship that reduces friction: they’re easy companions, so they choose proximity.
Example 2: The “buffer horse”
One horse is frequently seen near several different individuals, while others keep more distance from certain herd members. That can suggest this horse has broad tolerance and helps the group stay settled simply by being an easy neighbor.
Example 3: The “distance agreement”
A particular pair rarely stands close—even though neither seems aggressive. When they do pass, it’s with small, low-level signals (a head turn, a body angle change, a step aside) and then they separate again. That distance can be part of how the herd avoids escalation.

Why this beats the “alpha hierarchy” shortcut

When humans force a simple “alpha” story onto horses, they often miss the real structure: bonds, tolerance, distance, and timing. Proximity patterns let you see those quieter stabilizers—often the very things that prevent conflict from ever becoming visible.

A quick way to start observing

Pick one calm period each day and simply note: which two horses are closest, and does that pairing repeat tomorrow? Over time, those repeated choices tell you far more about herd relationships than a single dramatic moment ever will.

Bonds Without Bridles: Noticing How Horses Choose Connection in Shared Space

Hook What does "living with" horses truly look like when you never request performance, never mount up, and never transform each encounter into a training session? The answer is remarkably straightforward: you observe how they select one another. Connections within a herd aren't merely poetic additions—

When the Fence Faces Inward: Boundaries That Let Horses Stay Horses

Hook What if a boundary isn't something you construct to contain horses, but something you establish to remind yourself where you stop—and where their territory starts? For us, the most unexpected transformation occurred when we gave the horses access to most of the property and enclosed just

The Invitation in the Meadow: Letting Horses Include Us Without Riding

Hook What if “being with horses” isn’t something we do to them—an activity we organize—but something we are occasionally allowed into? When riding and training are off the table, the relationship stops being about compliance and starts being about access: access to their space, their routines, and

Breath as a Bridge: How Horses Read Our Quietest Signals

Hook If you spend enough time simply being with horses—no riding, no training, no agenda—you start to notice something humbling: they respond to what’s underneath your actions. Not just what you do, but what you are, moment to moment. And one of the most constant “tells” you